Advertisement

Advertisement

Advertisement

Advertisement

  1. Home
  2. /

  3. Formula Cars
  4. /

  5. Formula 1
  6. /

  7. News

Advertisement

Is the FIA being unfair? David Coulthard: Does athletics only involve one leg?

The way in which the FIA, the world motorsport governing body, assesses the performance of F1 engines is causing a stir. This is because adjustments are only made to the combustion engine side of the power unit, not to the electric system. David Coulthard is flabbergasted.

Formula 1

This article is an automatically generated English version. The Original Article was published in German.

Mentioned in this article


Advertisement

TV Program

Advertisement

Ahead of the traditional Grand Prix weekend, one thing is clear to the rule-makers at the FIA, the world motorsport governing body: Red Bull-Ford has the most powerful internal combustion engine. For this reason, their rivals – namely Ferrari, Mercedes, Honda and Audi – are permitted to develop their internal combustion engines, whilst Red Bull-Ford are not, all within the framework of the so-called ADUO.

Advertisement

Advertisement

ADUO stands for ‘Additional Development and Upgrade Opportunities’. The aim of ADUO is to ensure that engine manufacturers who are lagging behind are given a chance to make up the deficit during the season. Manufacturers are granted development leeway if they are at least two per cent behind in terms of internal combustion engine performance.

The FIA has published the results for the second ADUO phase (covering the World Championship races from the season opener in Australia up to and including Hungary before the summer break). It concludes that Mercedes is between 2 and 4 per cent behind the class leader in terms of performance; Ferrari, Audi and Honda are more than 4 per cent behind.

FIA Head of Formula Sport Nikolas Tombazis: “The FIA has carried out a thorough and comprehensive analysis as part of our ADUO review process. With the publication of the results of the second phase, we are confident that the analysis is extremely well-founded due to the quality of the data, which gives us a high degree of confidence in our findings.”

Advertisement

Advertisement

Red Bull Racing team principal Laurent Mekies has quite rightly criticised the fact that ADUO only takes into account the performance of the internal combustion engine (approx. 530 PS). The contribution of the electric system is disregarded. It is widely accepted within the industry that Mercedes has the most powerful overall package.

TV Program

Long-serving Formula 1 driver David Coulthard has echoed this sentiment in his podcast ‘Up to Speed’. The 13-time Grand Prix winner and 2001 World Championship runner-up strongly disagrees with the FIA’s approach here.

The driver, who has competed in 246 Grand Prix races, explains: “In Formula 1, there’s an old saying that aerodynamics is king, and that’s always been something of a mantra. We tend to talk more about aerodynamics than engine power, and there have been various examples of teams winning world championships without having the most powerful engine.”

“But I feel that a real opportunity has been missed here with ADUO. The FIA says it was the teams’ wish to have a correction mechanism that was as simple as possible, which ultimately led to only the internal combustion engine being taken into account as part of the power unit.”

Advertisement

Advertisement

“To me, that’s simply not fair. You inevitably ask yourself: why is this being done? It’s as if, in athletics for example, we were to introduce some sort of limit on a specific part of the body. Then people would also say: ‘Why is this only about one leg?’ Because in competition, the whole body is used, after all.”

“Applied to Formula 1: the power unit as a whole isn’t just about the internal combustion engine. It’s also about the electric side. Sorry, but I don’t think that’s the fairest mechanism for monitoring engine performance.”

“We must bear in mind just how enormously complex these power units are. Here’s an example: we know from McLaren that they were frustrated at the start of the year because, although they have the same power unit as the Mercedes works team, they only received all the relevant information a week before the race. That simply wasn’t enough time for McLaren to carry out simulations and determine the optimal energy distribution.”

“The bottom line is that we find ourselves in a classic situation where we all have to sit back and acknowledge: this isn’t the best solution.”

Advertisement

Advertisement

Seen already?

Don't miss out on any highlights: The Speedweek newsletter, sent out twice a week, delivers the latest news, exclusive commentary and all the important dates from the world of motorsports - directly into your inbox


Topics

  1. Results

  2. Championship Standings

Results

Full Standings
  1. Race

  2. Starting Grid

  3. Qualifying 3

  4. Qualifying 2

  5. Qualifying 1

  6. Sprint

  7. Starting Grid

  8. Sprint Qualifying

  9. 1 Free Practice

Pos
#
Driver
Driver
Team
Rounds
Time
Fastest Lap
Points

01

1

Lando Norris

McLaren Formula 1 Team

Lando Norris

McLaren Formula 1 Team

72

2:04:44,859

1:14,321

31

02

12

Kimi Antonelli

Mercedes-AMG Petronas Formula One Team

Kimi Antonelli

Mercedes-AMG Petronas Formula One Team

72

+11,536

1:14,571

23

03

63

George Russell

Mercedes-AMG Petronas Formula One Team

George Russell

Mercedes-AMG Petronas Formula One Team

72

+15,906

1:15,393

23

04

44

Lewis Hamilton

Scuderia Ferrari HP

Lewis Hamilton

Scuderia Ferrari HP

72

+16,755

1:14,566

14

05

16

Charles Leclerc

Scuderia Ferrari HP

Charles Leclerc

Scuderia Ferrari HP

72

+17,258

1:14,230

17

06

81

Oscar Piastri

McLaren Formula 1 Team

Oscar Piastri

McLaren Formula 1 Team

72

+32,332

1:14,303

12

07

30

Liam Lawson

Oracle Red Bull Racing

Liam Lawson

Oracle Red Bull Racing

72

+1:19,915

1:15,435

6

08

27

Nico Hülkenberg

Audi Revolut F1 Team

Nico Hülkenberg

Audi Revolut F1 Team

71

+1 round

1:16,048

4

09

14

Fernando Alonso

Aston Martin Aramco Formula One Team

Fernando Alonso

Aston Martin Aramco Formula One Team

71

+1 round

1:16,946

2

10

10

Pierre Gasly

BWT Alpine Formula One Team

Pierre Gasly

BWT Alpine Formula One Team

71

+1 round

1:16,220

2

Events

All Formula 1 Events
  • Past

    Mexican Grand Prix

    Autódromo Hermanos Rodríguez, Mexiko
    30.10. – 01.11.2026
  • Past

    Brazilian Grand Prix

    Autodromo Jose Carlos Pace, Brasilien
    06.–08.11.2026
  • Max Verstappen

    Live

    Las Vegas Grand Prix

    Downtown Las Vegas Street Circuit, USA
    19.–21.11.2026
  • Next up

    Qatar Grand Prix

    Losail International Circuit, Katar
    27.–29.11.2026
  • Next up

    Abu Dhabi Grand Prix

    Yas Marina Circuit, Vereinigte Arabische Emirate
    04.–06.12.2026
  1. Past

    Mexican Grand Prix

    Autódromo Hermanos Rodríguez, Mexiko
    30.10. – 01.11.2026
  2. Past

    Brazilian Grand Prix

    Autodromo Jose Carlos Pace, Brasilien
    06.–08.11.2026
  3. Max Verstappen

    Live

    Las Vegas Grand Prix

    Downtown Las Vegas Street Circuit, USA
    19.–21.11.2026
  4. Next up

    Qatar Grand Prix

    Losail International Circuit, Katar
    27.–29.11.2026
  5. Next up

    Abu Dhabi Grand Prix

    Yas Marina Circuit, Vereinigte Arabische Emirate
    04.–06.12.2026

Formula Cars News

All News

    Speedweek.com – The best motorsport on the web

    The latest news around the clock, analyzed and commented on by experts, with exclusive behind-the-scenes insights. Here, fans write for fans.

    Reports

    Editorial

    Series